Key Takeaways
- The Gen Z stare manifests in two primary forms: a vacant expression from service workers during perceived unreasonable customer interactions (customer service stare) and from Gen Z customers instead of verbal responses (customer stare) .
- Pandemic isolation critically impacted social skill development: Reduced face-to-face interaction during formative years limited practice with conversational norms and non-verbal cues for many Gen Zers .
- It’s often misinterpreted as rudeness or disinterest: Older generations may perceive the stare as disrespectful, while Gen Z frequently views it as a legitimate response to inauthentic or inefficient interactions .
- Underlying factors include heightened anxiety and authenticity values: Gen Z prioritizes genuine communication and may reject performative politeness, while also experiencing higher rates of social anxiety .
- Workplaces are adapting training programs: Organizations recognize gaps in soft skills like interpersonal communication and emotional intelligence, implementing targeted coaching to bridge generational divides .
What Exactly Is the "Gen Z Stare"? Breaking Down the Blank Expression
You’ve probably seen it – or felt it. That flat, unblinking gaze from a barista when you ask for an extra shot. Or the cashier who just… stares when you say "how’s your day going?" It’s everywhere on TikTok right now, labeled the "Gen Z stare". But what is it really?
Turns out, it ain’t just one thing. People are talkin’ ’bout two main versions:
- The Customer Service Stare: This is the look a Gen Z worker gives ya when they think your question or request is, well, ridiculous. Think asking a Starbucks worker if they sell Dunkin’ coffee. It’s that silent, deadpan response before they muster a flat "no" . TikTok user Santana nailed it: "the customer service stare is the stare a worker gives somebody for asking someone something f---- stupid" .
- The Customer Stare: Flip it around. This is when a Gen Z shopper or diner just looks at a service worker instead of answering. Like when a server asks "Still workin’ on that?" and gets nothin’ back but a blank gaze. No nod. No "yes thanks." Just… stare .
Folks describe it as vacant, kinda empty, super hard to read. Is it judgment? Boredom? Pure confusion? Professor Jessica Maddox (Uni of Alabama) sees it constantly in her classes. She’ll ask a question, and get met with total silence and these blank looks. She only realized it had a name – the Gen Z stare – after seein’ it blow up online .
"I don’t think it’s a lack of social skills. I just think we don’t care," says Gen Z TikToker Dametrius "Jet" Latham, whose video on the topic racked up over 1.4 million views . For many zoomers, it’s a deliberate non-response to what they see as pointless small talk or silly questions.
Why’s everyone talkin’ ’bout this now? Maddox thinks it really took off after everyone came back to campuses post-COVID. She noticed way more silence in her classes . Combine that with TikTok’s love for generational spats (#GenZStare has been used in thousands of vids), and boom – viral trend .
How COVID Lockdowns Rewired a Generation’s Social Skills
Let’s be real. Those pandemic years? They messed with everyone. But for Gen Z – especially teens and young adults – it hit different. This was prime time for learning how to chat, flirt, argue, make small talk… all that messy, awkward, essential human stuff. Instead? Screens. Isolation. Anxiety through the roof.
Professor Maddox connects the dots straight to the "Gen Z stare" phenomenon. "This [look] very much accelerated after we returned to campus after Covid protocols," she says, noting an "increasing amount of silence" in her classes . It makes sense. If you spend ages 16-20 mostly in your room on Zoom calls or group chats, you just miss out on practicing those thousands of tiny face-to-face interactions.
The numbers paint a tough picture:
- Mental Health Strain: Gen Z already reported higher anxiety and depression before COVID hit. The pandemic cranked that up. Social isolation, fear of the virus, financial worries about the future – it piled on . One study even found Gen Z members were less resilient during the crisis compared to Gen X .
- Screen Time Skyrocketed: Real-life hangs got replaced by DMs, TikTok comments, Fortnite chats. Gen Z’s whole way of connecting became digital-first. Fast, informal, often nonverbal. That doesn’t exactly prep you for smiling at grumpy customers or chit-chatting with your boss .
- Fear of "Cringe" & Cancellation: Growing up online means knowing anything you say could be screenshotted, mocked, or used against you. "Because most members of the generation don’t remember a time without social media, they fear anything they say or do could end up being mocked online – or worse, get them canceled," Maddox points out . Safer to stay silent and stare, maybe?
Psychotherapist Robi Ludwig frames it as a social skills gap. "We may take for granted some of the social skills we have developed over the years because we didn’t have technology to deal with and we didn’t have to be isolated from our peers," she suggests . Things like nodding, smiling, giving a simple verbal cue ("yep!", "gotcha") – these learned reflexes might not be as automatic for zoomers who missed key developmental practice.
Dr. Jean Twenge (author of Generations) puts it bluntly: "Social skills take thousands and thousands of hours to develop and adolescence is a critical period for developing social skills. And Gen Z has spent much less time with their peers in person during that critical stage" . It’s less about being rude, more about missing reps.
Beyond Rudeness: Why Gen Z Says the Stare Makes Perfect Sense
Okay, so older folks see a blank stare and think "Wow, rude." Or "Do they even understand me?" But zoomers? They’re pushin’ back hard online, explaining their side. And it’s way more than just laziness or bad manners.
#1 Defense: Efficiency Over Fake Niceness.
For many Gen Z workers drowning in low-wage service jobs, the stare is about cutting through the BS. Why waste energy fake-smiling and nodding through small talk they find pointless or draining? Caleb Worley breaks it down simply: "We stare when you don’t understand common sense" . If a question seems dumb or obvious, the stare says it all.
#2 Defense: Authenticity is King.
Gen Z hates fakeness. Professor Jennifer Grygiel (social media expert, Syracuse) sees this as key: "Gen Z values authenticity and holds a high bar... If interacting with them feels awkward, it might also be because they’re not only young, but haven’t had as much experience socializing out in the real world as other generations" . They’d rather be quiet than force a phony reaction.
#3 Defense: It’s Not Disengagement, It’s Processing (Their Way).
Joe Galvin from Vistage warns managers not to misread the stare as checking out. "What a Boomer or Gen X manager may perceive as checked-out might actually be Gen Z’s version of active listening," he argues . Constant eye contact doesn’t signal attentiveness the same way for a generation raised multitasking across screens.
#4 Defense: Overwhelm and Anxiety are Real.
Let’s not forget the context. Many zoomers entering cafes or stores as workers or customers are stressed. Debt, climate dread, political chaos, pandemic scars. Efe Ahworegba (19) captures this vibe online: "The Gen Z stare is basically us saying the customer is not always right" . Facing down another demanding interaction? Sometimes freezing up or zoning out is the brain’s response.
The "Lead Paint Stare" Counter-Jab:
Gen Z isn’t taking the criticism lying down. They’ve fired back by mocking older generations too – like the "lead paint stare" (attributed to Boomers looking confused) or the "millennial pause" (that awkward silence at the start of a video) . It’s the latest round in the eternal generational blame game.
The Workplace Clash: When the Stare Meets the Office
Walk into any store, cafe, or office lately, and you might spot it – the Gen Z stare happening live. For managers and older coworkers, it’s causing real friction. But experts say writing it off as "bad attitude" is a massive mistake. There’s a legit communication gap happening, and workplaces gotta adapt.
Why Bosses Are Worried:
- Communication Feels Broken: That silent stare instead of a "Got it, boss" or "I’ll check on that"? It throws off workflow. Managers report Gen Z struggles with professional tone (too casual in emails/chats), avoids phone calls, gives one-word replies, or misses important emails buried in their inboxes .
- Collaboration Suffers: If team members aren’t verbally engaging – just staring blankly in meetings or after instructions – how can you build trust or brainstorm effectively? Psychotherapist Robi Ludwig sees it as a skills gap: "If it’s a processing thing, it’s hard to imagine someone wouldn’t know how to nod or respond with a smile or just say ‘OK’" .
- Customer Interactions Get Awkward: That infamous customer service stare can leave patrons feeling ignored or disrespected. Imagine asking a simple question like "Where’s the restroom?" and just getting a silent look back. It’s bad for business .
Bridging the Gap (It’s Possible!):
Smart companies aren’t just complaining; they’re acting. The British Council identifies four key soft skills needing development :
- Interpersonal Communication: Teaching basics like maintaining rapport, mindful listening, adapting styles.
- Emotional Intelligence (EQ): Building self-awareness, self-regulation (managing stress!), and empathy.
- Presentation & Public Speaking: Boosting confidence in speaking up clearly and handling nerves.
- Business Writing: Moving beyond text-speak to professional emails and docs.
How Forward-Thinking Companies Are Adapting:
- Targeted Training: Ditch the boring lectures. Use role-playing real scenarios (e.g., handling a difficult customer, responding to a manager’s request). Show examples of "too casual" vs. "professional but friendly" chat messages and emails .
- Mentorship, Not Micromanagement: Pair Gen Z new hires with supportive (not judgmental!) Gen X or Millennial mentors. Focus on modeling desired behaviors and offering constructive feedback .
- Reframing Strengths: Consultant Sujay Saha advises leveraging Gen Z’s native skills. "Gen Z can help turbocharge social media marketing for your organization," he notes. They value authenticity? Use that to connect with younger customers! .
- Clarity is Kindness: Be super clear about workplace communication expectations. "Is a quick Teams message okay for this, or does it need an email?" Define response time expectations ("Try to reply to internal emails within 4 hours") .
The Bottom Line for Employers:
"Misreading body language or communication styles can create unnecessary confusion and frustration, as well as missed opportunities to connect," warns Joe Galvin . By 2025, Gen Z will be one-third of the workforce. Investing in bridging this communication gap isn’t optional; it’s essential for teamwork, customer satisfaction, and just getting stuff done.
The Authenticity Factor: Why Gen Z Rejects "Fake Nice"
So much of the tension around the Gen Z stare boils down to one core value for this generation: authenticity. They can smell fakeness a mile off, and they want no part of it. That forced retail smile? The scripted "Have a great day!" when it’s clearly been awful? To many zoomers, it feels dishonest, draining, and frankly, pointless.
Professor Jennifer Grygiel sees this firsthand. "I find Gen Z to be really great at having conversations," they say. "I would say that if you are actually engaging them, they will engage you back. Maybe what we're witnessing too is some boredom, especially with who they're interacting with... If there were more enriching interactions for them, interpersonal interactions, maybe more of their personality and the ability to talk and engage would kind of cut through that" .
It’s not (always) about being lazy or rude. It’s about rejecting performative emotional labor – especially in low-paid service jobs where they feel undervalued. Why pour energy into pretending to be delighted to serve someone demanding or dismissive? The blank stare becomes a shield, a way to opt out of a script they find demeaning or insincere.
This links directly to the "Customer Service Stare." As TikToker Efe Ahworegba (19) put it: "The Gen Z stare is basically us saying the customer is not always right" . That stare might be the only form of pushback they feel they can safely use.
The Flip Side: The "Customer Stare."
When Gen Z are the customers, that same desire for authenticity kicks in. They might not respond with the expected "Thanks!" or "You too!" because it feels automatic, not genuine. Or they might be overwhelmed navigating an interaction without the buffer of a screen.
It’s also about social energy. After years of pandemic isolation, casual in-person chats can feel surprisingly taxing. "65% of [Gen Z] said they struggle to make conversation with colleagues," notes a U.S. Harris Poll mentioned by the British Council . Silence, or a neutral stare, can feel safer than fumbling through small talk they find awkward or unnecessary.
Is this just youthful rebellion? Not entirely. Experts like Grygiel suggest it reflects a broader cultural shift Gen Z is leading, valuing realness over ritual. "[Young people] become the target of the critique of the social ills of our time... If some of the rhetoric is criticizing them or critiquing them, honestly, it's a reflection not of them — it's a reflection of society as a whole" . The stare holds up a mirror.
Not the First, Not the Last: Generational Judgement is Ancient History
Gen Z getting flak for their blank stares? Millennials got roasted for avocado toast and killing napkins. Boomers were called the "Me Generation." Gen X was labeled slackers. And get this – Plato was dissing the youth way back in ancient Greece.
"They disrespect their elders, they disobey their parents. They ignore the law. They riot in the streets inflamed with wild notions. Their morals are decaying. What is to become of them?" Sound familiar? That’s Plato in The Republic – over two thousand years ago! .
Every generation develops its own style, often as a reaction against the one before. Gen Z’s perceived silence or flat affect mirrors the blank, defiant stares captured in 80s teen movies like Pretty in Pink or Sixteen Candles . The "whatever" attitude of Gen X wasn’t so different in spirit.
The mediums change, the complaints stay weirdly similar. Social media, especially TikTok, just amplifies and speeds up these generational spats. "Internet culture loves a generational feud," notes Professor Jessica Maddox . Hashtags like #GenZStare or #OKBoomer turn subtle differences into viral battlegrounds.
Edith Cowan Uni lecturer Shane Rogers explains: "Generations have been doing these comparisons for time immemorial, but nowadays there is this medium that allows for those conversations to be ramped up... But the main users are millennials and gen Z right now, so that is where a lot of the conversation is at" .
What is different this time?
- The Pandemic Disruption: COVID lockdowns uniquely interrupted Gen Z’s social development in ways previous generations didn’t experience globally .
- Digital Ubiquity: Gen Z are true digital natives. Their primary social world formed online in a way that wasn’t possible for Millennials (who remember dial-up) or older gens .
- Economic/Climate Anxiety: Gen Z faces massive, well-publicized stressors – crushing debt, unaffordable housing, climate crisis impacts – shaping a more fatalistic or pragmatic outlook .
The "Millennial Pause" Parallel:
Remember zoomers mocking millennials for that brief, awkward silence at the start of every video? Gen Z called it cringe. Now, millennials are returning fire over the stare. It’s the circle of generational life! .
The takeaway? Labelling the Gen Z stare as some unprecedented social decay misses the point. It’s the latest chapter in an old, old story of youth navigating the world differently than their elders. Understanding why it manifests now (pandemic + digital life + economic stress) is more useful than just calling it rude.
The Stare as a Mirror: What Our Reaction to Gen Z Says About Us
That uncomfortable feeling when a Gen Z cashier just stares instead of smiling back? The frustration when a young coworker stays silent after you explain a task? It’s easy to point the finger at them – "They’re rude!" "They lack social skills!" But experts suggest the Gen Z stare reflects something back on us, the observers.
Professor Jennifer Grygiel puts it powerfully: "[Young people] become the target of the critique of the social ills of our time. Because in order to feel optimistic as a society, as a culture, you need to feel good about the next gen. And if some of the rhetoric is criticizing them or critiquing them, honestly, it's a reflection not of them — it's a reflection of society as a whole" .
Think about it. We (older gens) handed Gen Z:
- A planet facing climate disaster they’ll inherit .
- Skyrocketing education costs and unaffordable housing .
- The social media landscape we built (and often failed to regulate) .
- A global pandemic that upended their schooling and social lives .
Is it any wonder their default mode isn’t bubbly enthusiasm? That blank stare might be resignation, overwhelm, or a refusal to play a game they see as rigged. Calling it "rude" might just be our way of avoiding harder questions about the world we shaped for them.
The "Freeze" Response Makes Sense Contextually.
Psychologically, freezing is a trauma response (fight/flight/freeze). While not suggesting everyday interactions are traumatic, constant low-grade stressors (news cycles, economic fears, pandemic residue) can prime the nervous system. Joe Galvin even describes the stare as resembling "a deer caught in the headlights" – a classic freeze reaction . For a generation reporting high levels of burnout and anxiety , the stare might simply be mental overload.
Our Interpretation Reveals Our Biases.
When a Boomer manager sees a silent Gen Z employee, they might interpret it as defiance or stupidity. But as Galvin notes, "For many Gen Zers, constant eye contact doesn’t always signal attentiveness the way it might for older colleagues" . What looks like "not paying attention" might actually be their way of focusing. Our assumptions say more about our expectations than their intentions.
The Path Forward: Less Judgment, More Curiosity.
Instead of labeling the Gen Z stare as a problem, what if we asked:
- "Is this interaction meaningful, or just performative?" (Challenging our own need for scripted niceness).
- "Are we creating environments where genuine engagement feels possible and worthwhile?"
- "How can we meet their need for authenticity while building necessary communication bridges?"
The stare isn’t going away. How we choose to see it – as a threat or a reflection – is up to us.
Frequently Asked Questions About the Gen Z Stare
Q1: Is the Gen Z stare real, or just a TikTok trend?
It's a real observed behavior amplified by TikTok. While not every Gen Zer does it, the pattern of prolonged, blank stares in response to questions or interactions – particularly in service settings – has been widely noted by educators, managers, and customers, and heavily discussed online (#GenZStare). Professor Jessica Maddox observed it consistently in her university classes post-COVID . TikTok provided the label and viral platform.
Q2: Why do Gen Z workers give the "customer service stare"?
Gen Z workers often describe it as a reaction to perceived unreasonable, illogical, or overly demanding customer requests or interactions. It's a non-verbal way of expressing disbelief, disapproval, or simply opting out of forced, inauthentic niceness. As TikToker Santana clarified, it's the look given "for asking someone something f---- stupid" . It can also stem from anxiety, overwhelm, or uncertainty in fast-paced service roles.
Q3: Why do Gen Z customers just stare instead of answering service workers?
This "customer stare" can have several causes: rejection of perceived unnecessary small talk (inauthenticity), social anxiety making verbal responses difficult in the moment, simple distraction, or processing information differently (e.g., needing more time to formulate a response than older generations expect) . For some, it might be a passive resistance to performative service interactions.
Q4: Is the Gen Z stare caused by social media or the pandemic?
It's likely a combination. The pandemic critically limited face-to-face social interaction during key developmental years for many zoomers, reducing practice with conversational norms and non-verbal cues . Growing up immersed in digital communication (texts, DMs) prioritizes brevity and lacks the nuance of in-person interaction, shaping different habits . Social media provides the context for labeling and discussing the behavior.
Q5: How should managers handle the Gen Z stare in the workplace?
Experts advise against punitive approaches or assuming rudeness. Instead:
- Provide Clear Communication Training: Focus on soft skills like interpersonal communication, emotional intelligence, and professional tone using role-playing and real examples .
- Clarify Expectations: Explicitly state desired responses (e.g., "A simple 'okay' or 'I'll get that done' helps me know you understood").
- Foster Psychological Safety: Ensure Gen Z employees feel comfortable asking questions or admitting confusion without judgment.
- Check Interpretations: Ask clarifying questions like "What are your thoughts on that?" instead of assuming silence means understanding or defiance .
- Leverage Mentorship: Pair Gen Z employees with supportive mentors from older generations to model effective communication.
Q6: Are other generations guilty of similar behaviors?
Absolutely! Gen Z has mocked:
- The "Millennial Pause": That brief, awkward silence at the start of a video recording .
- The "Lead Paint Stare": A term Gen Z uses to describe Boomers looking confused or befuddled (referencing actual lead paint exposure concerns in older generations) .
- Gen X had its "whatever" apathy and blank defiance immortalized in 80s movies .
Critiques of younger generations' manners are a historical constant, as noted by quotes from ancient Greece .
Q7: Will the Gen Z stare fade as this generation ages?
Probably, but not completely. Core Gen Z values (authenticity, efficiency, rejection of performative emotion) may persist, shaping how they communicate long-term. However, as they gain more workplace experience and social confidence through practice, the frequency and intensity of the blank stare in everyday interactions will likely decrease, especially with supportive training and shifting workplace norms . The underlying desire for genuine interaction, however, is likely here to stay.
Comments
Post a Comment