CBS News Ombudsman Crisis: Skydance Merger Imposes ‘Hall Monitor’ on Journalism, Ends DEI & Sparks Bias Fears After Trump Settlement
CBS News Ombudsman Crisis: Skydance Merger Imposes ‘Hall Monitor’ on Journalism, Ends DEI & Sparks Bias Fears After Trump Settlement
Key Takeaways
- Skydance eliminated Paramount’s DEI initiatives immediately post-merger, replacing them with merit-based hiring
- An ombudsman role, dubbed a “hall monitor” by CBS staff, will investigate bias complaints, reporting directly to Skydance CEO David Ellison
- CBS faces internal backlash over historical DEI programs like BIPOC writer quotas and gender-specific hiring
- The network’s controversial Trump coverage, including a $16M lawsuit settlement, fueled Skydance’s push for oversight
The $8 Billion Handshake
Paramount and Skydance sealed their deal. Just like that. Eight billion dollars traded hands. Papers signed. David Ellison owns the circus now. CBS News employees sipped stale coffee. They read the press release. Nobody cheered. The new boss scrapped DEI initiatives on day one. Stephanie Kyoko McKinnon, Skydance’s legal spear, wrote the FCC. “We confirm the elimination,” it stated. Merit would replace race and gender metrics. Compensation ties to DEI? Gone. Paramount had started this unraveling months earlier. But Skydance finished it. A CBS insider called the welcome gift a “hall monitor.” Not flowers. Not bonuses. A watchdog .
Skydance’s First Moves:
- DEI Dismantled: Hiring goals and diversity benchmarks erased
- Policy Shift: Talent pools broadened without race/gender quotas
- Internal Reaction: Anonymous staff describe “no ringing endorsement” of news division
The Ombudsman Cometh
Meet the hall monitor. A corporate inspector. Independent? Maybe. This ombudsman digs into complaints, public or internal. Biased reporting? They investigate. Their findings skip CBS presidents. Go straight to Ellison’s desk. One CBS veteran shrugged. Ombudsmen existed before. But context twists the knife. Who gets the job? What power do they wield? Another insider whispered: “It depends on the individual.” Editorial sway versus rubber-stamp authority. The newsroom feels the stare. Every story draft. Every script edit. Someone’s watching now .
“When the welcome gift of the new owner is a hall monitor, it isn’t exactly a ringing endorsement.”
, CBS Insider
DEI’s Corpse on Campus
Remember CBS’s DEI era? Stephen Colbert did it bluntly. In 2018, he told The New York Times he refused writing samples from men. “Please don’t send us anyone but women,” he ordered. Got 87 submissions. Hired accordingly. George Cheeks, CBS president, mandated numbers. Reality shows: 50% BIPOC contestants. Primetime writers’ rooms: 40% BIPOC. The mentorship program? Seven writers picked from 1,000. Not one White male. Tiffany Smith-Anoa’i championed it. “Build relationships,” she told Deadline. Now Skydance calls that discrimination. They torched the quotas. Meritocracy is the new gospel. Staff wonder: Who defines merit?
Dead DEI Initiatives at CBS:
Trump, Lies, and Videotape
Skydance didn’t buy blind. CBS News bled credibility wounds. Trump sued. Twice. Remember Lesley Stahl dismissing Hunter Biden’s laptop? “We can’t put on things we can’t verify,” she said in 2020. CBS authenticated it two years later. Then came the Kamala Harris debacle. An edited 60 Minutes interview hid her Gaza war stumble. Trump sued Paramount. Got $16 million. Margaret Brennan cut J.D. Vance’s mic mid-debate. Conservatives screamed bias. Skydance heard them. The ombudsman isn’t for journalism. It’s for lawsuits. Ellison protects his investment. Truth? That’s secondary .
CBS’s Controversy Timeline:
- 2020: Stahl rejects Hunter Biden laptop story
- 2022: CBS authenticates laptop
- 2024: $16M settlement for Harris interview edit
- 2024: Brennan mutes Vance during VP debate
Hall Monitors of Yore
Ombudsmen aren’t new. The Washington Post had one. NPR too. They listen. Investigate. Publish critiques. But this feels different. Poison flows in the veins. CBS staff recall past monitors as toothless. Academic exercises. This one reports to Ellison, a Hollywood player, not a newsman. His father founded Oracle. Tech money bought a news division. Now it demands surveillance. The insider’s words hang heavy: “It depends on the individual.” Meaning: A crusader could gut stories. A puppet changes nothing. Trust evaporated before the ink dried .
Colbert’s Empty Chair
The Late Show stage darkens in May 2026. Stephen Colbert exits. His legacy? A writers’ room built on exclusion. “It wasn’t enough to say you want it,” he confessed. “You have to go to the not ordinary step.” He meant hiring women deliberately. Aggressively. Skydance sees that as not ordinary discrimination. Colbert leaves amid this reckoning. No farewell tour for DEI. Just cancellation. Literally .
Ellison’s Invisible Hand
David Ellison stays quiet. Lets lawyers talk. His general counsel’s FCC letter frames DEI’s end as “commitments moving forward.” Corporate speak. Clean. Bloodless. But the ombudsman hire? That’s his fingerprint. A direct pipeline to the president’s desk. CBS journalists grind teeth. Autonomy dies with one signature. Ellison builds planes in movies. Now he’s engineering news. Blueprints hidden. Hangar doors locked .
Newsrooms and Ghost Ships
CBS isn’t alone. Media fractures everywhere. The Washington Post bled readers. CNN bled credibility. Now CBS bleeds freedom. Beijing buys Iranian oil through ghost ships, untracked, unseen. CBS staff feel like those tankers. Navigating dark waters. New owners. New rules. No beacon. The ombudsman watches. The DEI past is condemned. The future? A byline under surveillance .
Frequently Asked Questions
Why did Skydance eliminate CBS’s DEI programs?
Skydance deemed DEI initiatives discriminatory. General Counsel Stephanie Kyoko McKinnon confirmed their elimination to the FCC, replacing them with merit-based hiring and broad talent pools .
What power will the CBS ombudsman have?
The ombudsman investigates public and internal complaints about bias, reporting directly to Skydance CEO David Ellison. Their influence depends on the appointee’s editorial authority, a point of internal contention .
How did CBS’s Trump coverage influence the merger terms?
CBS faced lawsuits over perceived anti-Trump bias, including a $16M settlement for editing Kamala Harris’s Gaza remarks and dismissing the Hunter Biden laptop story. Skydance’s ombudsman role directly addresses these credibility issues .
What were CBS’s most controversial DEI policies?
Mandates included 50% BIPOC reality show contestants, 40% BIPOC writers in primetime, and mentorship programs excluding White men, all scrapped post-merger .