Study: Deporting Unauthorized Immigrants Could Speed Up Social Security Collapse

Key Takeaways

🚨 Undocumented workers contribute $24B/year to Social Security but receive zero benefits, creating a net financial gain for the system .
📉 Mass deportations could move Social Security’s insolvency date from 2034 to 2033, triggering 19–23% benefit cuts for retirees .
👵 Immigrants fill critical gaps in elder care, making up 25% of direct care workers (nursing aides, home health aides) .
💡 Policy solutions exist: Pathways for care workers, updated visa caps, and payroll tax adjustments could stabilize the system .
🚫 Amnesty for undocumented immigrants would add $1.3T in costs to Social Security/Medicare by making them eligible for benefits .

Most people don’t realize Social Security gets a massive subsidy from workers who’ll never collect a dime. Last year alone, undocumented immigrants paid $24 billion into the system through payroll taxes—often using fake or expired Social Security numbers . That’s not loose change. It’s a direct cash infusion that keeps benefits flowing to retirees today.

How does this work? Simple economics. These workers pay FICA taxes on every paycheck, but federal law blocks them from claiming retirement, disability, or Medicare benefits. One immigration lawyer I spoke with put it bluntly: “They’re propping up a system that treats them as criminals.”

The irony’s thick. Politicians demanding crackdowns rarely mention this $24 billion annual subsidy vanishing if those workers get deported. And vanish it will—because unlike citizens, these workers don’t get replaced. Birth rates in the U.S. keep dropping (just 1.67 kids per woman), so new native-born workers aren’t filling the gap .

Let’s talk numbers—’cause the Penn-Wharton study lays it out cold . Three deportation scenarios, same grim result:

Projected Impact of Trump Deportation Plans

See that “+0.5 years sooner”? That means insolvency hits in 2033 instead of 2034 . When the trust fund dries up, automatic 19% benefit cuts kick in. Grandma’s $1,976 check shrinks to $1,600.

Why such huge losses? Deporting workers removes their payroll taxes today—taxes funding current retirees. But it doesn’t remove future retirees (U.S. citizens) who’ll still demand benefits in 2040 or 2050. Less money in + same money out = faster bankruptcy.

The Caregiver Crisis: Why Immigrants Aren’t Replaceable

Here’s something else folks miss. It’s not just about taxes. Who’s gonna wipe brows in nursing homes when 10,000 baby boomers turn 80 every day?

Immigrants make up 25% of all direct care workers—home health aides, nursing assistants, hospice helpers . In places like California or Florida, it’s closer to 40%. And demand’s exploding:

700,000 new home health aide jobs needed each year through 2032
U.S. faces a shortage of 355,000 paid caregivers by 2040

Without immigrants, facilities limit new patients. Half of nursing homes already do this because they’re understaffed . My aunt saw it firsthand when hunting for her mom’s dementia care—4 facilities had waitlists. One administrator told her, “We’ve got 10 beds empty and no one to bathe or feed people.”

Raise wages? Sure, but Medicaid reimbursements haven’t kept pace. Tech like remote monitors? Helpful, but they don’t change adult diapers.

Policy Solutions That Won’t Torpedo Retirement

1. Caregiver Visa Pathways

Create 50,000–100,000 visas/year for certified nursing aides and home health workers. Fast-track applications with Schedule A updates (last revised in 1991!) .

2. Adjust Permanent Immigration Caps

Green card limits haven’t changed since 1990—even though the economy’s 123% larger . Increasing caps by 37% could stabilize the worker-to-retiree ratio .

3. Payroll Tax Tweaks

Scrap the $168,600 cap so high earners pay FICA taxes on all income
Hike the tax rate gradually from 6.2% to 7.2% (85% of Americans support this)

4. Avoid Amnesty Pitfalls

Legalizing undocumented workers adds $1.3 trillion to entitlement costs because they gain benefit eligibility . Better to keep them working without amnesty—controlling borders while protecting current taxpayers.

The 2034 Cliff: What Happens If We Do Nothing

Social Security’s trustees updated their forecast this June:

Combined trust funds run dry in 2034 (one year sooner than last year’s projection)
Automatic 19% benefit cuts follow
Medicare Part A insolvency hits in 2033—89% of hospital benefits only

Why the speed-up? Two reasons:

Social Security Fairness Act added costs by boosting benefits for 3.2 million public pensioners .
Record numbers are claiming early—1.8 million filed through May 2025 (up 17%) . Anxiety about insolvency’s driving this rush.

Myths vs. Facts: What Politicians Won’t Tell You

FACT: Federal law prohibits it. Only green card holders with 5+ years of work qualify .

❌ “Immigrants drain the system!”

FACT: Legal immigrants are net fiscal contributors. Their kids earn more degrees and pay more taxes long-term .

❌ “Deportations save money!”

FACT: Removing undocumented workers costs Social Security $73–$884 billion over 30 years .

No. It’s illegal. Only legal residents who’ve worked 10+ years with valid Social Security numbers qualify .

Undocumented workers pay $24 billion/year in payroll taxes but can’t claim benefits. Deporting them removes this subsidy without reducing future retirees .

Its trust funds will deplete by 2034 without reforms. After that, payroll taxes cover only 77–81% of benefits—forcing automatic cuts .

4. How could immigration reforms help?

Visa pathways for caregivers and updated green card caps would add workers whose taxes fund retirees. One study estimates a 37% immigration boost stabilizes the system .

5. Do immigrants take Americans’ caregiving jobs?

No. Native-born participation in direct care work is declining. Immigrants fill shortages that otherwise leave elderly without care .

The Bottom Line: Kicking out undocumented workers won’t “save” Social Security—it will starve it. Smart policy keeps them paying in, while letting more caregivers work legally. Otherwise, that 2034 benefit cut becomes inevitable.

Finance Foggle

Search This Blog